Arts · 2 sourcesFR
French singer Amanda Lear accuses Miley Cyrus of plagiarism
French disco singer Amanda Lear has publicly accused American pop star Miley Cyrus of plagiarising her 1970s song ’The Sphinx’ in Cyrus’s new track ’Redlights.’ Lear, who was a muse to Salvador Dalí and former lover of Rolling Stones guitarist Brian Jones, made the accusation during a press conference in Paris. However, Lear later stated that she was not interested in pursuing legal action against Cyrus.
Consensus +0.4 (right-leaning) · spread +0.4 · furthest: Inquirer +0.7
leftcenterright
Inquirer+0.7France 24+0.0
What The Reports Agree On
- ✓French singer Amanda Lear accuses Miley Cyrus of plagiarising her 1970s song ’The Sphinx’
- ✓Lear made the accusation on Monday
- ✓The disputed new track is titled ’Redlights’
- ✓Lear stated she is not interested in a lawsuit
Where They Diverge
Level of legal threat implied
Inquirer Opens with Lear taking Cyrus to task over similarities; presents plagiarism accusation as the main thrust without mention of Lear’s disclaimer
France 24 Reports the plagiarism accusation but specifically notes Lear’s explicit statement that she was not interested in a lawsuit, adding nuance about legal escalation
Additional biographical context provided
Inquirer Extensive background on Lear’s career as a model, her relationship with Dalí, and her relationship with Brian Jones
France 24 Focuses narrowly on the accusation and Lear’s legal stance without biographical elaboration
Editorial Positioning
Inquirer +0.7Foregrounds plagiarism accusation as serious grievance; foregrounds Lear’s celebrity credentials and relationships; omits Lear’s disclaimer about not suing until near end
France 24 +0.0Reports accusation neutrally but includes Lear’s own clarification that she is not pursuing legal action; minor emphasis on Lear’s status as ’French disco diva’
Source Reports
French singer Amanda Lear accuses US star Miley Cyrus of ’copying’ 1970s hit
French disco diva Amanda Lear accused Miley Cyrus on Monday of plagiarising her 1970s song "The Sphinx" in the US pop star’s new track, "Redlights". However, Lear later added that she was not interested in a lawsuit.
French singer accuses Miley Cyrus of plagiarism
PARIS, France — French disco diva Amanda Lear publicly accused American singer Miley Cyrus on Monday of plagiarising one of her songs from the 1970s. Lear, a model-turned-singer who was a muse to surrealist painter Salvador Dali and a lover of Rolling Stones guitarist Brian Jones, took Cyrus to task over apparent similarities between her song “The Sphinx” and the American’s new track “Redlights”. READ: Miley Cyrus, now a true pop star, returns to her ‘Hannah Montana